Wednesday, August 2, 2006

4.1 Raid Gear guide Archive


Since 4.1 is here it is time to update the list.

The Changes for Patch 4.1:

  1. Patch 4.1 will add two heroic level 5-man dungeons that will drop epic level loot. This loot has a lower ilevel then raid loot but I'm sure some of you will be wondering how it stacks up. At this point I don't know which bosses and from what instances these items drop, but I will updated it when that information is known.

  2. I deleted most of the Blue level gear from the list. There are a few exceptions in the trinket section, but I assume that most people are beyond heroic 5mans and don't need the complete list. If you do need the complete list, I have link to the archived list at the bottom but that list will not be maintained.

  3. I updated the stat weights to represent a higher level of gear. The overall stat priority didn't change, but the value of Hit did decrease a little while the value of Mastery increased a little. This did cause a couple of things to shift on the list slightly but nothing dramatic.

  4. There were also several error corrections and added an item that was missed in the previous list.



The Usual Disclaimer Comments:

  1. This list is a tool, not a blueprint for how to gear. I’ve never intended my lists to be the definitive guide on how to gear a raiding moonkin. I don’t want to see any comments anywhere that say “item X is the best because it’s ranked number one on Graylo’s list.”

  2. The use of this list requires some thought. It is a general ranking intended to give you an idea on how items relate to each other. Please realize that these values are estimates based upon a fairly high gear level. Two items with a similar value, can be assumed to be relatively equal. Also, realize that your gear level may be different then the one I used. As a result you may value the stats differently. I highly suggest you look at this post to determine how you value stats. It's a little out of date, but the instructions at the bottem are mostly correct.

  3. It is up to you to manage your Hit cap. Do not take every number one item on the list.

  4. PvP and Healing gear are by definition not good PvE gear for moonkin. As a result I have excluded almost all items that are obviously PvP or healing related from the list. That said there are some exceptions. Healing trinkets that provides Int are included eventhough the proc is clearly healing because Int is such a good stat for moonkin. That said I don't suggest you take these items over a healer who needs it.

    None of this is to say you can't or shouldn't use these items in your own set depending on your situation. I exclude them because I like to keep the lists short, and they generally fall at the bottom of the list when comparing gear of a similar ilevel. If you wold like to figure out where they fall please feel free to do the math yourself using the weights I've provided below.

  5. Procs are particularly hard to quantify. Trinkets and other items that have procs or on use abilities are estimated in the list. However, it is likely that some of them are wrong given that we know very little about some of the procs. I will update them if I can, but I make no guarentees.

  6. Cloth: All cloth gear is excluded from this list. Equipping a single piece of cloth will cause you to lose 5% of your Int. In some very rare situations a cloth item might be better then the leather gear you currently have available to you. However, the gain would still be fairly small, and it's really not worth the effort.

  7. Resto Tier Gear: I have include the Resto Tier gear in the list since Spirit now converts to Spell Hit for Moonkin. However, it will not count towards you Set bonuses. Since Spell Hit is a highly valued stat many of the resto items are ranked higher then the Moonkin Tier. The other cause of this is that the set bonuses are not included in the valuation. Feel free to use a resto tier item, but realize you should use at most one.


Assumptions:

  1. To rank these items I used the following weights Intellect - 1.000 Spellpower - 0.7794, Spirit/Hit Rating - 0.5910, Haste Rating - 0.5261, Crit Rating - 0.2759, Mastery Rating - 0.3855. These are the weights that WrathCalcs spit out for a gear set I created using 359 ilevel gear.

  2. I assume that all socket bonus will be met using Superior quality gems. This is how I socket each gem: Meta = [Burning Shadowspirit Diamond], Red/Prismatic = [Brilliant Inferno Ruby], Yellow = [Reckless Ember Topaz], Blue = [Purified Dremonseye]. Yes, ignoring socket bonus will improve some of the items. This is particularly true if the socket bonus isa secondary stat like Crit or Mastery. However, the shifts in value should be small and it's easier manage this way.


Ranking Legend:

I've added two columns to the rankings. Here are the Explinations of all of the columns.


  • Natural - Black - This is a simple volume times rate calculation and assumes you can use every stat.

  • Reforge - Blue - This column adjusts the Natural ranking by reforging Crit or Mastery into Haste or Hit. This column assumes you need the hit, but Haste is given the priority of being reforged to since it can't be capped realistically.

  • Natural No Hit - Red - Same as the Natural column but excludes any valuation from Hit Rating or Spirit.

  • Reforge No Hit - Green - This column adjusts the Natural No Hit ranking by reforging Crit or Hit into Haste or Mastery.





Legs:


















NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Undertow (H) Al'Akir - Heroic702.7702.7550.2586.9
Stormrider's Leggings - MOONKIN (H) LotFV + 359 item700.3700.3560.2593.4
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Wavecrest (H) Al'Akir - Heroic669.3682.6516.8553.5
Leggings of the Consuming Flames (H) Maloriak - Heroic662.2674.8492.6533.5
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Feverflare (H) Al'Akir - Heroic653.8673.3642642
Stormrider's Legwraps - RESTO (H) LotFV + 359 item642.3665.8490.4526.6
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Fireflash (H) Al'Akir - Heroic627.7657.6615.9626.3
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Undertow Al'Akir - Normal625.2625.2490.4522.4
Stormrider's Leggings - MOONKIN 2,200 VP623.9623.9500.9529.9
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Wavecrest Al'Akir - Normal596607.6461.2493.3
Leggings of the Consuming Flames Maloriak - Normal589.8600.9437.4474
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Feverflare Al'Akir - Normal582.5599.5570.7570.7
Stormrider's Legwraps - RESTO 2,200 VP573.1593.9438.4470.4
Gale Rouser Leggings of the Fireflash Al'Akir - Normal559.6585.8547.8556.9
Leggings of the Pride 532.8550.3412.9444.1



I recommend going with the Tier legs here, because they have spirit which you are going ot have a hard time getting once you start getting a full tier set and they factor in to the set bonus. Gale Rouser Leggings of the Undertow are slightly better in terms of pure stats, but don't complete the set bnous. The two with out spirit on them would be significantly better then the tier legs if you don't need the hit, but I don't think many people will be in that situation.



Head:











NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Stormrider's Helm - RESTO (H) Vendor - EotF885885733.2769.4
Healm of the Blind Seer (H) Atramedes - Heroic832.9852.5663.3723.3
Stormrider's Cover - MOONKIN (H) Vendor - EotF805.4837.5793.5804.7
Stormrider's Helm - RESTO Token - Normal Nefarian808.6808.6673.9705.9
Camouflage Bio-Optic Killshades BoP Crafted783.8783.8783.8783.8
Healm of the Blind Seer Atramedes - Normal763.8780.6611.3665.5
Stormrider's - MOONKIN Cover Token - Normal Nefarian738.1766.8726.3736.3
Amani Headdress 736746.4626.6665.6



If I was going to pick up a resto tier item, this is the slot I would do it it. You're trading Crit for Spirit and picking up a little more Haste as well. The problem is that the head slot is the most difficult tier item to get. I'm not sure I would want to only have the resto item in this slot when we transition to Tier 12.


Shoulders:












NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Passive Resistor Spaulders (H) ODS - Heroic513.4513.4406.5434.3
Stormrider's Mantle - RESTO (H) Token485.4494.9372.5412.5
Stormrider's Shoulderwraps - MOONKIN (H) Token470.2485.8470.2470.2
Hide of Chromaggus (H) Zone Drop - BWD462.5479.5343.7385.8
Passive Resistor Spaulders ODS - Normal455.9455.9361.9386.2
Stormrider's Mantle - RESTO Token - Cho'gall430.9439.2331366.2
Stormrider's Shoulderwraps - MOONKIN Token - Cho'gall417.1430.8417.1417.1
Hide of Chromaggus Zone Drop - BWD410.4425.2304.6342
Feathers of Akil'zon 424.3424.3336.3356



The Moonkin tier shoulders are ranked down the list because all the items above them have spirit. I am planning on sticking with the tier gear at this moment to complete the tier set bonuses.


Chest:











NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Scorched Wormling Vest (H) Magmaw - Heroic651.9667.3511.9557.1
Stormrider's Robes - RESTO (H) CotFV Token586.3607.9574.5588.8
Stormrider's Vestmants - MOONKIN (H) CotFV Token585.2607.8573.4587.2
Scorched Wormling Vest Magmaw - Normal579.6593.5456.7496.1
Stormrider's Robes - RESTO 2,200 VP523.2541.9511.3524.1
Stormrider's Vestmants - MOONKIN 2,200 VP522.1541.8510.2522.4
Chestguard of Nature's Fury Crafted508.1533.9508.1517.1
Vestments of the Soulflayer 489509.5477.1487



The moonkin tier chest isn't awesome, and many moonkins are going off set in this slot and using the Schorched Wormling Vest. However, I prefer to do something different. I think going off set at the head slot provides slightly better stats, and the heroic chest token is easier to get then the Scorched Wormling Vest. Therefore, I'm sticking with the tier chest.


Hands:










NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Stormrider's Handwraps - RESTO (H) GotFV Token514.7514.7396426.8
Hydrolance Gloves (H) TAC - Heroic475.1486.3374.1409.8
Stormrider's Gloves - MOONKIN (H) GotFV Token451.4476.6451.4460.2
Stormrider's Handwraps - RESTO 1650 VP457.2457.2351.4378.8
Hydrolance Gloves TAC - Normal420.6430.6332.6363.6
Stormrider's Gloves - MOONKIN 1650 VP400.8423.1400.8408.6
T'wansi's Handwraps 399.3407.8301.8332.3



I would go with the moonkin Tier once again.


Wrists:






NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Manacles of the Sleeping Beast (H) Chimaeron - Heroic354.7362.7270.2300.2
Manacles of the Sleeping Beast Chimaeron - Normal314321.1239265.3
Armbands of the Bear Spirit 285295208.1235.5



Unless you get really unlucky like me, the raid level bracers should be fairly easy to get. If you do get unlucky then there are a nice pair from the new 5mans.


Belt:
















NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Gale Rouser Belt of the Undertow (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic507.6507.6401.2429
Gale Rouser Belt of the Wavecrest (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic482.3492.4376413.8
Gale Rouser Belt of the Feverflare (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic470.7485.4470.7470.7
Belt of the Nightmare (H) Nefarian - Heroic454.3474.3341.4377.2
Gale Rouser Belt of the Fireflash (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic450.9473.6450.9458.8
Lightning Lash BoE Crafted460460371.9394.7
Gale Rouser Belt of the Undertow Conclave of Wind - Normal451.2451.2356.7381.4
Belt of the Untamed WC Rep Reward447.7447.7341.9369.3
Withered Dream Belt DC Rep Reward447.7447.7341.9369.3
Gale Rouser Belt of the Wavecrest Conclave of Wind - Normal428.8437.8334.2367.9
Gale Rouser Belt of the Feverflare Conclave of Wind - Normal418.4431.5418.4418.4
Gale Rouser Belt of the Fireflash Conclave of Wind - Normal400.8421400.8407.9
Belt of the Nightmare Nefarian - Normal402.2420302.4333.4



I hope most of you have your Dragonmaw Clan or Wildhammer Clan Rep maxed out already and have the Epic belt. From there the best place to improve your belt slot is by going with on of the random stat belts off of Conclave of the wind.


Boots:








NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Nightmare Rider's Boots (H) Sinestra533.4544.8424.7458.9
Treads of Hideous Transformation (H) Cho'gall - Heroic467.9484.9343.2383.2
Fading Violet Sandals 1650 VP445.7445.7357.7380.4
Treads of Hideous Transformation Cho'gall - Normal415.8430.6304.1339.3
Two-Toed Boots 381.2401.4381.2388.3



The two heroic options are clearly what most people will want, but I bet most of us will be wearing the Fading Violet Sandals for while. They are purchaseable with Valor Points, which we should have a lot of once we buy the available tier gear.


Back:













NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Shroud of Endless Grief (H) Sinestra378.5391378.5378.5
Drape of the Twins (H) V&T - Heroic374.7374.7290.2312.2
Drape of the Twins V&T - Normal331.9331.9256.8276.1
Ritssyn's Ruminous Drape BoE - World315.8326.1315.8315.8
Shadow of Dread (H) Nefarian - Heroic309.6323.9309.6317.6
Heavenly Breeze 1250 VP314321.1239265.3
Haunt of Flies 1250 VP291.8307.6291.8297.3
Hakkari Loa Drape 296.7302.7221.7248
Shadow of Dread Nefarian - Normal274286.5274281
Spiritcaller Cloak 271.6285.1217.8236.7



While our choices were limited in the leather slots, they are huge in our non leather slots because we have all the Spirit items to choose from as well as the non spirit items. If you have excess gold Ritssym's Ruminous Drape isn't bad for a world drop. Haunt of the Flies is also a nice Valor Point cloak.


Neck:










NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Valiona's Medallion (H) V&T - Heroic345.4357.1345.4345.4
Wyrmbreaker's Amulet (H) Halfus Wyrmbreaker - H:BoT339353.2254.4284.4
Valiona's Medallion V&T - Normal305.8316.1305.8305.8
Dorian's Lost Necklace World Drop304.5313.7304.5304.5
Wyrmbreaker's Amulet Halfus Wyrmbreaker - BoT300.1312.6225251.3
Lightning Flash Pendant WC - Rep Reward274286.5274281
Yellow Smoke Pendant DC Repreward274286.5274281



Since you have been leveling up DC/WC rep for the belt you should also pick up the the Epic neck they provide as well. It's not ideally itemized but it's better then the blue necks available after it's reforged.


Trinket:





















NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Darkmoon Card: Volcano DMF Quest493.7511.7493.7511.7
Theralion's Mirror (H) V&T - Heroic509.2509.2509.2509.2
Heart of Ignacious (H) TAC - Heroic481.3481.3481.3481.3
Figurine - Jeweled Serpent BoP Crafted470.5470.5470.5470.5
Theralion's Mirror V&T - Normal450.2469450.2469
Bell of Enrageing Resonance (H) Atramedes - Heroic420.5456.8420.5420.5
Vibrant Alchemist Stone BoP Crafted453.1453.1453.1453.1
Heart of Ignacious TAC - Normal444.7444.7444.7444.7
Stump of Time Rep Reward439.9439.9250.2317.5
Witching Hourglass (H) Obsidius - H:BC434.9434.9434.9434.9
Bell of Enrageing Resonance Atramedes - Normal371.5403.5371.5371.5
Soul Casket 1650 VP374392374392
Fall of Mortality (H) Cho'gall - Heroic363363363363
Tyrande's Favorate Doll Archaeology353.7353.7353.7353.7
Sarrowsong (H) Siamat - H:LCotT310.3326.3310.3326.3
Core of Ripeness 1650 VP321321321321
Darkmoon Card: Tsunami DMF Quest321321321321
Fall of Mortality Cho'gall - Normal321321321321



Take these trinket valuations very lightly. In many cases I don't know what the internal cooldown is on the proc, and had to make an educated guess. I think I was fairly conservative in my estimates but who knows. I do want to make one quick note. Trinkets with a lot of Crit or Mastery may seem unattractive at first. However, several of them have very nice procs, Plus don't for get that you can forge that Crit or Mastery to Haste or Spirit. They can give you quite a bit of flexibility if needed.


Rings:


























NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Planetary Band of the Undertow (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic373.7373.7289.2311.2
Planetary Band of the Flameblaze (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic353.7361.7269.2299.2
Planetary Band of the Wavecrest (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic353.7361.7269.2299.2
Segnet of the Fifth Circle (H) Cho'gall - Heroic345.4357.1345.4345.4
Planetary Band of the Feverflare (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic344.4356.1344.4344.4
Security Measure Alpha (H) ODS - Heroic339353.2254.4284.4
Planetary Band of the Wildfire (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic338352.2253.4283.4
Planetary Band of the Fireflash (H) Conclave of Wind - Heroic328.7346.6328.7334.9
Planetary Band of the Undertow Conclave of Wind - Normal330.7330.7256.3275.6
Twined Band of Flowers 1250 VP314321.1239265.3
Planetary Band of the Flameblaze Conclave of Wind - Normal313.1320.1238.6264.9
Planetary Band of the Wavecrest Conclave of Wind - Normal313.1320.1238.6264.9
Ring of the Boy Emperor Archaeology305.8316.1305.8305.8
Segnet of the Fifth Circle Cho'gall - Normal305.8316.1305.8305.8
Planetary Band of the Feverflare Conclave of Wind - Normal304.9315.2304.9304.9
Security Measure Alpha ODS - Normal300.1312.6225251.3
Soul Drain Signet 312.1312.1244.7262.1
Shimmerclaw Band 311.9311.9236.8256.1
Planetary Band of the Wildfire Conclave of Wind - Normal299.2311.7224.8251.1
Signet of High Arcanist Savor BoE - World297.6310.7226.1251.4
Band of Secret Names 1250 VP291.8307.6291.8297.3
Planetary Band of the Fireflash Conclave of Wind - Normal291306.8291296.5
Signet of Venoxis 289.4299.3289.4289.4



This list is huge. The reason is there are a lot of rings out there and there is a ring with random stats. At the 359 ilevel you can find a lot of rings from nontraditional sources like Archeology, Valor Points, and World drops, plus the ones you can get from raiding. There are fewer options at the heroic level, but there looks to be a lot because of the random stat rings.

The only question I have about this slot is if you can use two of the Planetary Band rings at the same time. The tool tip says they are unique equip, but I don't know if that is for the entire class of ring or if you could use two of them with different stats.




Off Hand:









NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Book of Binding Will (H) Halfus - Heroic374.7374.7290.2312.2
Scepter of Ice (H) TAC - Heroic354.7362.7270.2300.2
Book of Binding Will Halfus - Normal331.9331.9256.8276.1
Scepter of Ice TAC - Normal314321.1239265.3
Heartbound Tome World Drop313.2319.5234261.9
Lost Bag of Whammies 278.9291.4215237.7



I always thought it was a little unfair that Shaman and Paladins could enchant their shilds and other casters couldn't enchant their off hands. That is no longer true, and significantly shifts the weapon debate in favor of the MH/OH combo. The Apple-Bent Bough was a clear choice for me before epics since it was purchase able with Justice Points.


Main Hand:













NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Andoros, Fist of the Dragon King (H) Nefarian - Heroic1992.71998.91927.71950.9
Incineratus (H) Magmaw - Heroic1985.61994.61985.61985.6
Twilight's Hammer (H) Cho'gall - Heroic1973.51987.41973.51978.3
Blade of the Witching Hour (H) V&T - Heroic1958.11969.11958.11964.2
Andoros, Fist of the Dragon King Nefarian - Normal1763.81769.21706.51726.5
Incineratus Magmaw - Normal1757.51765.31757.51757.5
Twilight's hammer Cho'gall - Normal1746.91758.81746.91751
Blade of the Witching Hour V&T - Normal1733.31742.81733.31738.6
Amani Scepter of Rites 1668.31673.41613.91632.9
Voodoo Hexblade 1652.21663.61652.21656.2



When it comes to weapons the only thing you should really care about is ilevel, because it predetermines how much Spell Power and Int an item has. For example, The Biting Wind is the worst ranked 345 weapon, but it's only 2% worse then the highest ranked blue weapon. In short, ilevel is king in this slot.


Two Handed Weapon:







NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Chelley's Staff of Dark Mending BoE - BoT2087.62100.31952.82000.7
Staff of Ammunae Archaeology2062.52085.31927.81975.6
Staff of Sorcer-Thane Thaurissan Archaeology2047.72076.42047.72057.7
Legacy of Arlokk 1960.31977.91960.31960.3



The nail in the two handed coffin is that there are really no good two handed options. There are a couple of 359 epic staffs, but I'm not sure if the heroic option even exists. If a staff is a clear upgrade then use it, but remember it has to be an overwhelming improvement to make up for the 40 Int enchant you lose on the off hand. In short, avoid staves.


Relic:





NameLocationNaturalReforgeNatural No HitReforge No Hit
Relic of Eonar 700 VP213.5220.4167.1181.9
Relic of Norgannon 700 VP205215.2205207.5



This choice really comes down to spirit or no spirit. Once you make that choice which one you want is obvious. The only other comment I would make is that even though the Tattooed Eyeball is listed last it's not that much worse then the other options. Given that it is easy to obtain it is a very attractive option.



Archived Gear Lists:

4.0 Gear list

Notes:
Once again, as you can see there are a lot of links and values in this post. It is quite possible that some of them are incorrect. If you find an incorrect link or a valuation just doesn't look right, please let me know so that I can correct it.

No comments: